How not to post in a newsgroup...

Published Mon, Jan 31 2005 19:47 | William

I was just watchign CNN and it appears that KC's brilliant CAPTCHA article edged out the Iraqi elections in terms of interest.  If I can just put something in perspective:

From microsoft.public.dotnet.languages.csharp:

<<I would like to know how to write a spyware program.>>

One every count this post is just wrong.  Ignore for a second the moral implications. 

First he made a statement and didn't ask a question. 

Second, “Spyware” is a bit vague and short on details. 

Third, he's asking for information that, if provided, would probably help him faciliate committing a crime.

Now for the good part.  He only got 4 responses.  Three of them telling him why he's an idiot and one telling him how to do it.  This is in a Microsoft newsgroup by the way.  The sheer stupidity of it alone qualifies it as spam or trollbate. Two MVPs pointed these facts out to him.  Anyone want to bet me that KC  has caught crap from more than 2 MVPs?  [Please also note that I respect the heck out of a lot of people that were bothered by this - I just don't happen to agree with their indignation].  But I ask, who's more likely to cause problems, KC or script kidde wannabe? 

I can already hear the replies “Well, that dude is just an idiot, he won't be able to pull it off anyway” or “He didn't actually write any spyware”.  IF that's the case, then please tell me how posts like this in newsgroups are less of 'spam' than what Casey did?  If we're going to get self-righteous here - at least we should be a little more consitent about it?

---------

KC - please note that since now we are officially members of the MVP Leper colony - you're obliged to hang out with me at the summit and post some pictures  of TS ;-)

Filed under: , ,

Comments

# William said on January 31, 2005 9:31 PM:

thats a great idea! my next article should be 'how to write spyware'

# William said on January 31, 2005 9:45 PM:

LOL!

And, yes, there is a difference. Quite a huge difference. We can pretend to not know the difference between 'asking a moronic question' and pulling a stunt.

In fact Casey, I think showing how to write spyware is perfectly fine. In fact, providing that tool probably wouldn't even be bad. In that case, using it it...

Hard things, these judgement calls eh?

# William said on January 31, 2005 10:42 PM:

is that a question?
if so ... the answer is no

and what makes you think my previous post was a joke. you really have no way of knowing

# William said on January 31, 2005 10:57 PM:

Looks like we really did it now ;-(.

# William said on February 1, 2005 12:12 AM:

I'll buy you both a drink.

Speaking of which - I need to get you my cell # for next week....

# William said on February 1, 2005 10:35 AM:

I'm still laughing at the thought of that KC - your wit is great - and afaik - you're being serious which is even better.

Search

This Blog

Tags

Community

Archives

News

My other sites

Cool Stuff

Book Stuff

Security

ORM

Data Access

Funny Stuff

Compact Framework Stuff

Web Casts

My KnowledgeBase Articles

My MVP Profile

Design Patterns

Performance

Debugging

Remoting

My Fellow Authors

My Books

LINQ

Misc

Speech

Syndication

Email Notifications