An interesting solution to the Outsourcing 'Problem'

Published Tue, May 18 2004 8:43 | William

As a radical free market type of guy, I tend to get embarassed when I hear people whining about outsourcing.  We aren't owed jobs and we don't own them.  If you can't find a job you need  to learn a few new tricks, plain and simple.   Few of the anti-outsourcing people seem to get lost on the irony of the fact that they almost assuredly use products made in foreign countries to complain about foreign competition.  So if it's ok for them to use a computer made in another country, why isn't it ok for other people to use software or services made in another country?  Why is it right to force other consumers to pay higher prices because you can't do the same work someone else can for cheap?  And there are certianly instances where outsourcing projects blow up and people make bad mistakes about their outsourcing choices.  That's called the free market and it will correct itself.  Always does, always has (unless you get the government involved).

Anyway, of all the solutions to this supposed 'problem', the fact that it markets correct themselves isn't brought up that often.  What that means is that India is bursting at the seams with brilliant, hardworking and talented people.  In the same vein there are many challenges inherent in working across continents.  Some times those challenges cause big problems.  Some times companies find tremendous value.  Over time people learn from their mistakes, people overseas will work to elminate those challenges and we're all better off for it. Personally, I'd rather just have an “Aid to dependent IT Workers” welfare program for those guys that can't find jobs if the only alternative is protectionism...it's a heck of a lot cheaper.

But all of this discussion may in fact be academic  b/c India may end up doing the same thing Japan did, and regrettably the US  may do.  The few victories government's have in helping problems are eclipsed by all the messes they make.  Hopefully this won't happen to India b/c all that fearmongering about outsourcing is rubbish.  The US will benefit tremendously from outsourcing just as it benefits from immigration.  Imagine how back out IT industry would suck if we didn't have any foriegners working in it?

Comments

# William said on June 19, 2005 6:11 AM:

Offshore Outsourcing is ok if you have a clear view of the things. For example India and Romania imports cars, computers, coca-cola, movies, MS Windows and in return they offer work force. See for example <a href="http://www.romsourcing.com">ROMsourcing.com</a> , they are renting(!) highly educated operators in a Bucharest office for only $30/day (all expenses included). It is at least a fair deal. Don`t you think!?

Search

This Blog

Tags

Community

Archives

News

My other sites

Cool Stuff

Book Stuff

Security

ORM

Data Access

Funny Stuff

Compact Framework Stuff

Web Casts

My KnowledgeBase Articles

My MVP Profile

Design Patterns

Performance

Debugging

Remoting

My Fellow Authors

My Books

LINQ

Misc

Speech

Syndication

Email Notifications