HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

Slow and Drops Connection

Samuel D. — Sun, 20 Jul 2008 03:55:50 GMT

I was working with an HP 47" TV with the Media Extender option integrated into it. When I go to connect it to any of my many different systems, both vista and xp the system is so slow and lagged out I might as well forget about it. Also if i do actually get to streaming any content off of the computers it often disconnects every 15 to 20 minutes at which point i have to restart the gateway server. Anyone suffer from these issues? Any suggestions? Im thinking about just building a dedicated media center system to hook directly to the TV.

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

Naffy — Fri, 11 Jul 2008 04:32:31 GMT

Has anyone compared these to the NetGear EVA8000? It doesn't have the MCE experience, but it plays back a bunch of stuff -- in 1080p via HDMI.

HP MediaSmart Connect Demo at HP’s SmartHome | eHomeUpgrade

HP MediaSmart Connect Demo at HP’s SmartHome | eHomeUpgrade — Tue, 08 Jul 2008 21:20:40 GMT

Pingback from HP MediaSmart Connect Demo at HP’s SmartHome | eHomeUpgrade

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

Sam Blackburn — Tue, 08 Jul 2008 12:35:30 GMT

I canceled my order for the Connect based on your review. I have an HP MediaSmart Server that holds all of my music & video. I wanted a box that would convert those bits on the server into an HDMI audio/video signal. Kind of like a DVD player only without the discs. I took that $350 and applied it to building a PC to do the same job as the x280n. I wound up going $38 over budget but got 2.6GHz dual-core 2GB system with 160GB hard drive and a mother board (ASUS M3N78 PRO) capable of doing 1080p with HDMI. I'll run Vista Media Center on it so I should be able to play anything.

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

Sean — Mon, 07 Jul 2008 02:12:36 GMT

Does this play ISO files?

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

Anthony Parker — Sun, 06 Jul 2008 13:14:16 GMT

Is there a DVD drive you can use in the Media Driver Bay instead of a HD?

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

Mark — Sat, 05 Jul 2008 15:43:45 GMT

The question for me is whether this is worth almost $100 premium over the Linksys. I trust HP to make some improvements and seemingly are more likely to add some functionality with firmware updates than Linksys as an OEM, but right off the bat I cannot see $100+ worth of added value if the underlying hardware is the same. Makes me think I should go for Linksys and then hold out for v3 extenders which might have slightly more juice for the animation/transitions etc within Media Center.

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

surge — Fri, 04 Jul 2008 16:57:11 GMT

A couple of questions for you:

Your review shows that the HP can play XVID files with AC3 audio.

Do you also have a Linksys extender?

If so, are you aware of the issue the Linksys has where when playing an XVID/AC3 file, the audio cuts in and out over and over?

Can you play one of those files on the HP without an audio problems?

And does the Closed Caption button on the HP remote send a code that only the HP unit understands or can you use the remote on the Linksys unit?

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

Darryl — Thu, 03 Jul 2008 16:02:42 GMT

> ...your only hope is to have an AVR that decodes WMA Pro.

Sounds like it's too late for this generation of the product, but multi-channel PCM over HDMI is what I'm looking for, not transcoding. As long as the decoders are decent, that would be my first choice for AC3 as well, although that's less of an issue for AC3 since most receivers have built in decoders for that format. Maybe you could pass that on to your contact at HP.

links for 2008-07-03 | Get A New Browser

links for 2008-07-03 | Get A New Browser — Thu, 03 Jul 2008 12:40:21 GMT

Pingback from links for 2008-07-03 | Get A New Browser

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

chrisl — Thu, 03 Jul 2008 03:26:27 GMT

If it has a fan I can't hear it at all. The thing is dead silent in all operating conditions.

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

Mark — Thu, 03 Jul 2008 03:04:05 GMT

You mentioned silence, does the Connect have a fan or not? Thanks.

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

chrisl — Thu, 03 Jul 2008 01:26:20 GMT

Darryl: I'm asking about this, but it isn't transcoded to Dolby Digital so your only hope is to have an AVR that decodes WMA Pro. And even then I'm not sure if it supports bitstream output of WMA Pro (I'm asking now).

JohnCz: There are newer Sigma processors on the market now, it is just the time to design and develop around them. I'm hoping the increased speed of these newer editions will give the boost they need. These newer chips can handle BD-J from Blu-ray Discs so I assume the extra power is used there, so why not Extenders.

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

Wed, 02 Jul 2008 23:36:42 GMT

Good to see a decent remote included. Disappointed with the 264 mp4's result though. I was hoping for solid playback even if it was only 2 channel. The 2100 plays them with audio but it stutters bad at parts.

Project HTPC » Blog Archive » links for 2008-07-02

Project HTPC » Blog Archive » links for 2008-07-02 — Wed, 02 Jul 2008 20:32:20 GMT

Pingback from Project HTPC » Blog Archive » links for 2008-07-02

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

JohnCz — Wed, 02 Jul 2008 16:57:46 GMT

Chris, thanks for the great write-up. Its good but not great. For me, it comes down to price and performance. At $350, there is no reason for menu transitions/animations/etc not to be very responsive and fluid. I hope that it is something which can be resolved via a upcoming Media Extender firmware upgrade. But if the Sigma processor is not powerful enough..then you've got ask yourself why they pushed for this Sigma design to be used. Keeping my fingers crossed that the Media Extender Team has an update in the works.

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

Darryl — Wed, 02 Jul 2008 16:01:22 GMT

What about support for WMA Pro as an audio-only format? Music is more important than video for me. I converted some of my 5.1 channel audio discs to WMA Pro and was wondering if this extender can handle it.

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

Bud — Wed, 02 Jul 2008 15:56:21 GMT

Downmixing to two channel audio via HDMI...why would they cripple the audio for HDMI users?

re: HP MediaSmart Connect Review Part 3: Extender & Conclusion

hd — Wed, 02 Jul 2008 12:49:18 GMT

I bought an HP Mediasmart TV with this function built in. It was the only thing I liked about the TV. It definitely worked, but the server software that had to be installed on the computer would drop occasionally. I do recall a lag issue, and now that i think about it, it was a pain. I never knew if the computer went offline or not, so I had to keep checking it. Overall, though, I thought it was a good idea that worked acceptably.

I'd have kept the set, if it only looked good. The TV itself was terrible (black levels were just blobs of black), so I returned it. But the Mediasmart end of things was decent. For this to be integrated into a TV is definitely an idea whose time is here.

Now I use a networked Vista MC laptop connected to a Philips HDTV, which looks and works much better.