Click Here to visit Embedded Automation - mControl
Short Bits: Digital Copy, tru2way, Big Media - Chris Lanier's Blog

Short Bits: Digital Copy, tru2way, Big Media

Remember just last month when I said “I’d like to see companies embrace the fact that DVD is still the mainstream format?”  Based on a story in CED from this past week studios are starting to realize that’s the key, with one Warner exec saying “….64 percent of consumers said having a digital file gives better value.”  This story was about including protected digital copies of films on DVDs (Example) which I think is a great idea and needs to happen much more often (on all DVDs).  Now let’s also see it work the opposite way too, if I buy a digital download allow me to get the physical DVD at a discounted price (or free? Yeah right)

I know I haven’t covered tru2way much yet, but that’s because there isn’t much to say.  Quickly, tru2way is CableLabs basically renaming the CableCARD 2.0/OCAP platform.  Of course a large majority of the media doesn’t understand any part of it; CNET even asked if tru2way can succeed where CableCARD failed.  Just so we are clear, tru2way is a platform for CableCARDs.  It’s now a two-way platform instead of one-way like all previous devices.  It will require use of the exact same CableCARDs (which are all two-way).  MegaZone did a good job explaining it, yet CNET didn’t retract the article or edit it despite the fact it is 100% incorrect.  Two-way CableCARD for Media Center isn’t likely to appear until Windows 7.

Speaking of CNET (now owned by CBS), anyone else find it ironic that big media conglomerates have purchased these smaller outlets which still post on things like breaking copy protection on DVDs?  Hey CBS, if your new media outlets are going to report on breaking copy protection, let’s just skip the formalities and disable things like CGMS-A on Showtime, AACS on CBS Blu-ray Discs, CSS on DVDs, etc.

Published Saturday, June 07, 2008 1:52 PM by chrisl

Comments

# re: Short Bits: Digital Copy, tru2way, Big Media

Chris, I've been trying to find an answer for this.  What happens to CGMS-A when digital becomes the standard, and all analog tv stops broadcasting?

Saturday, June 07, 2008 4:50 PM by Jeffrey

# re: Short Bits: Digital Copy, tru2way, Big Media

You can add CGMS-A on output from an STB.  Since it is only supposed to be used on cable/sat, it isn't an issue to add it during the output (S-Video, etc).

Saturday, June 07, 2008 5:17 PM by chrisl

# re: Short Bits: Digital Copy, tru2way, Big Media

I'm not following your point on tru2way... sure current cablecard (the cards) are 2 way capable but none of the current cablecard tuners are 2 way devices.

If you are trying to make the distinction between the functionality of the tuner and the card, so be it, but CNET saying cablecard has failed is an accurate assesment since current cablecard tuners are one-way.  So, to-date, cablecards have been a failure.

Well... current cablecard "tuners" have failed... because the cable companies wanted them to (since they cut off existing sources of revenue).

It's still early but tru2way "appears" to actually have the backing of the cable companies because it allows them to retain their existing revenue streams (ondemand, SDV, etc.) and allows them to add new functionality (interactive content, integration with other media distribution services that may be IP based, etc.).

Sunday, June 08, 2008 3:43 PM by Al

# re: Short Bits: Digital Copy, tru2way, Big Media

Al: I think you need to go back and read the CNET article.  They clearly don't understand what tru2way is, which is the point I'm making.  Case-in-point, they say flat out "...that's effectively what Tru2way is: the next-gen CableCard, without the physical card."  What?  tru2way is not CableCARD without the CableCARD.

Cable companies still don't like CableCARD because they still don't get to charge you $15/month for their STBs if you pick another device.  It does have the backing of a few major CE companies, which is very important, but that's a big difference from the cable companies liking the change.

Will tru2way be more of a success than current CableCARD products?  You bet!  Is this the development that does away with STBs like many sites are saying right now?  No.  It is sure an upgrade from v1 though.

Sunday, June 08, 2008 4:05 PM by chrisl

# re: Short Bits: Digital Copy, tru2way, Big Media

Ahhh... gotcha... you are right I didn't read the article and by reading your post I didn't understand what your issue was with CNET's article.  Thanks for clarifying.

The cable companies don't care much about the box rental fees.  If they did they would just charge more for the cablecard rental.  They care about the fact that they lose ondemand revenue, payperview event revenue and the fact that it prevents their move to SDV.

Monday, June 09, 2008 8:25 PM by Al