Click Here to visit Embedded Automation - mControl
Automatic Commercial Skip in Media Center! - Chris Lanier's Blog

Automatic Commercial Skip in Media Center!

Everyone should know about DVRMSToolbox that lets you do just about anything with your Recorded TV files.  However, the more time that goes by the more I see that people are not taking advantage of what DVRMSToolbox has to offer.  Today I wanted to give everyone a basic introduction to one of the coolest features, automatic commercial skipping!

DVRMSToolbox can automatically process your recordings using the Commercial Skin Add-in so that when you play them back (PC or Extender) you don’t have to touch a single button to skip commercials.

Setup is very simple, download and install DVRMSToolbox and ensure you check the option to Register the Commercial Skip Add-in as part of the install.  Reboot after this, and then make sure the rest of your setup is correct.  That’s it!

Start playing a Recorded TV program and Media Center will give you a prompt about Commercial Skip.  Say Yes to process it and before the first commercial (in most cases, generally takes 5-8 minutes) the show will be entirely processed and skip over the commercials without any fast forwarding. For newly recorded shows, FileWatcher runs in the background and automatically runs ComSkip on the files.  So the next day you go to watch them, the ComSkip scanning has already happened.

If you are in Vista, remember to read Mike’s article on getting Commercial Skip working.  Both are free, although donations for both are well worth it.  ComSkip Donations & DVRMSToolbox Donations.

And remember, DVRMSToolbox does so much more!  Convert to WMV, Convert to MPEG, Sync to PocketPC’s, etc.

So, have you tried out DVRMSToolbox and are you using Commercial Skip?  If not, what exactly are you waiting for?

Published Fri, Feb 16 2007 10:35 by chrisl

Comments

# re: Automatic Commercial Skip in Media Center!

Hi Chris, so this is something that sounds very cool. And I already manually skip over commericials anyway. But every time I do, there's a wee voice at the back of my head telling me that it's the commericials that subsidise my cable bill. By skipping them ( according to the wee voice) I'm effectively cheating the system.

But then this other wee voice says that I hate being subjected to really bad commercials. The same wee voice also says that if everyone starts skipping commercials, then maybe it will force the networks and advertising companies to come up with a system that actually respects the viewer and gives them some kind of control over the advertising they watch - presumably coupled to how much it subsidises their cable bill.

I suppose I was just wondering what your thoughts on this were. Do you - or anyone else reading for that matter - ever feel guilty skipping commercials? :)

Friday, February 16, 2007 11:12 AM by Ross

# re: Automatic Commercial Skip in Media Center!

once again, shame i dont work in the uk with digital tv

Friday, February 16, 2007 12:51 PM by adrian davies

# re: Automatic Commercial Skip in Media Center!

So, I've often thought about setting this up but never really gotten around to it.  Reading this has me thinking about it again.

Question:  How reliable have you found this?  Out of 100 commercial breaks (for example), roughly how many does it correctly identify beginning and end, and how often will it make a mistake (including missing the commercial)?

I'm just curious, thanks.

Friday, February 16, 2007 1:44 PM by Aaron

# re: Automatic Commercial Skip in Media Center!

Commercial detection is handled by by ComSkip (free) or ShowAnalyzer ($10); both are very reliable OOTB,  SA is faster and it supports "Live" detection (it can scan files as they are recorded) if commercials aren't detected properly you can "tune" either one, ShowAnalyzer comes with a slick GUI tool that makes this process much easier.

90% of the time commercial detection is perfect.  I've only had to "tune" to deal with shows like soccer, where the commercial breaks are 15 min long.

Friday, February 16, 2007 2:11 PM by andy vt

# re: Automatic Commercial Skip in Media Center!

"Out of 100 commercial breaks (for example), roughly how many does it correctly identify beginning and end"

More than you're getting now? ;)

Friday, February 16, 2007 2:12 PM by Dave Zatz

# re: Automatic Commercial Skip in Media Center!

I've had a great experience with ComSkip.  I wouldn't forget about having a remote near-by, but with me ComSkip almost always hits ~2 seconds about the commercial break starts, some comes back to the show ~0.5 seconds before the show starts.  It's perfect, you might hear the start of the commercial, but then it picks right up at the show.

Friday, February 16, 2007 2:34 PM by chrisl

# re: Automatic Commercial Skip in Media Center!

Thanks guys.  I think I found a project to tackle this weekend :)

Friday, February 16, 2007 2:34 PM by Aaron

# re: Automatic Commercial Skip in Media Center!

I downloaded and installed DVRMSToolbox to convert record TV files into regular video files, but I found the application's GUI very lacking. The interface was not intuitive and there were no help files, so I uninstalled it. I'll wait until this or another program like it are more ready for prime time are more polished. As it is right now, it needs serious help from a graphic/UI designer.

Saturday, February 17, 2007 9:02 AM by Jaxim

# re: Automatic Commercial Skip in Media Center!

All you need to do in DVRMSToolbox is install it, reboot, and make sure ComSkip is the preferred analyzer.  The rest of it happens within Media Center in a standard 10 foot UI prompt.

If you need help, I'd be glad to help you get it going.  :)

Saturday, February 17, 2007 9:08 AM by chrisl

# Davis Freeberg’s Digital Connection - Hollywood Killed Replay But Can They Take On Microsoft?

# Zatz Not Funny!»Blog Archive » Hollywood Killed Replay But Can They Take On Microsoft?

# Automatically skip commercials using Windows Media Center

Chris Lanier provides a tutorial on setting up the Media Center editions of Windows XP and Vista for automatic commercial skipping using DVRMSToolbox: Everyone should know about DVRMSToolbox that lets you do just about anything with your Recorded TV ..

Saturday, February 24, 2007 10:43 AM by Cool Tech Reviews

# Recording Broker Does Conflict Resolution With Networked Pool of Tuners

Recording Broker Does Conflict Resolution With Networked Pool of Tuners This looks awesome. If only I had extra tuner cards and a spare PC with a media centre license! Recording Broker - ...

Wednesday, April 25, 2007 2:28 AM by My Nerdthings.com News

# Windows Media Center Questions - Overclock.net - Overclocking.net

Pingback from  Windows Media Center Questions - Overclock.net - Overclocking.net