Click Here to visit Embedded Automation - mControl
CableCARD On Approved PCs Only, Thomas Hawk and Jim Allchin - Chris Lanier's Blog

CableCARD On Approved PCs Only, Thomas Hawk and Jim Allchin

My (Thomas Hawk) Dinner With Microsoft Exec Jim Allchin | Thomas Hawk got the chance to have dinner with Jim Allchin again a few days ago.  I would encourage everyone to read Thomas’ write-up since I’m only going to cover part of it.

Thomas: "Although as a platform Vista has been approved by CableLabs at this point, an important step that will still be necessary for the PC/CableCARD reality is CableLab's approval for finshed individual OEM PCs as well. Although Vista has been approved, OEMs will in fact still need to get their individual machines certified by CableLabs as well. Central to this certification according to Jim is the idea of a "protective path." "

So, Allchin has confirmed that OEM PCs as a whole will have to be certified.  This likely means that you will not be able to build a PC yourself that will work with CableCARDs.  Apparently Jim said “protective path” is a big part of this, and if you have ever read my blog you should know a thing or two about that.

Thomas: “Getting something approved through CableLabs is no easy task and this will very much favor the larger OEMs who have the funds, resources and clout to get this done. Jim said to expect to see the CableLabs approved PCs out from the big guys first but reiterated his commitment to smaller OEMs in fighting for them to also get their machines CableLabs approved as well. Jim said that Microsoft would fight clawing and scratching for these smaller OEMs. It will be interesting to see between now and Fall what that will mean.”

Funds?  Interesting part there.  Are we to think that for a PC to be certified it will have to be submitted to CableLabs on approved testing dates and pay to have it tested?  I don’t remember the amount, but having a product tested by CableLabs comes with a rather large price tag.

Update: Is Allchin Mistaken on CableCARD Facts?
Published Sun, Jan 29 2006 11:03 by chrisl

Comments

# re: CableCARD On Approved PCs Only, Thomas Hawk and Jim Allchin

http://htpcnews.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=19901

Linked to your post, and some more information about the DirecTV card from Sean Alexander.

Sunday, January 29, 2006 4:35 PM by SpHeRe31459

# re: CableCARD On Approved PCs Only, Thomas Hawk and Jim Allchin

That's a pretty big and bad news for htpc fans cause many of them are building their media centers.
It's gonna sucks big time if for having cablecard you have to buy a Sony etc.. media center.
Hope this changes.

Sunday, January 29, 2006 8:48 PM by Yacine

# re: CableCARD On Approved PCs Only, Thomas Hawk and Jim Allchin

If DirectTV comes out with a card as eluded to by Sean Alexander, I'll move off of cable without any regrets. I just want my HTPC and HDTV.

Monday, January 30, 2006 11:58 AM by Foster