Using Beta, Alpha or CTP releases in production environments - should it be risked?

Ok, i'm probably one of the keenest geeks out there when it comes to trying out new software/applications/frameworks/components..hell you name it and i'll install anything i get my hands on and play with it...

now that statement is most likely going to get me smacked severely...but i should say in closing to that comment - on my home PC..yes guys and gals.i'll install it on my home pc and NEVER ever use it in a production environment if it had any type of importance.

Seriously - commercially it's suicide..who's to say that the Beta/CTP release is stable enough to even perform as expected?

I will admit that i've added a few goodies from Beta and CTP levels to applications...but never have i attempted to use something i hadn't tested 100% and was absolutely convinced that it would be working just fine..but would i do it on a mission critical application? would i use it on a clients application? or what about a commercially sold application, off the shelf style??

the answer here is simple..no i would not..but James Avery would..now having read his book "Visual Studio Hacks" i'm somewhat surprised at that post.

I don't normally hunt other bloggers - especially not people in James's caliber - i mean, i have a great deal of respect for the man...but here's something which i'm honestly shocked to read..

I'm sure that James weighed up the chances with this gamble - which he's saying that he's now paying for - but was it a gamble that should even have been entertained in the first place? in my opinion i'd say no, but then again...i'm not quite in the same level as james is - by far. 

Could be that i was misunderstanding what i'm reading? it is getting late here..sooooo i'll leave it at that..

Maybe i should pop back over to his blog and suggest he starts up a list of the bugs he encountered so we can all learn from them at this stage of the framework's development....

Published Thu, Sep 7 2006 0:16 by Brian Madsen

Comments

# re: Using Beta, Alpha or CTP releases in production environments - should it be risked?

Wednesday, September 06, 2006 11:21 AM by James Avery

I probably should have stated how much we have used it. We have it on probably 5-6 pages in our application (and this is a 200 page application). We were testing it out, which is why it will be do easy to switch out for Ajax.NET or another AJAX framework.

# More on Atlas

Wednesday, September 06, 2006 6:25 PM by .Avery Blog

More on Atlas

# re: Using Beta, Alpha or CTP releases in production environments - should it be risked?

Wednesday, September 06, 2006 9:01 PM by Brian Madsen

Fair comment James...

the surprise from me was merely that the impression was that you were adapting the release into the entire project - and not "testing" or "trying it out" as such.

I'm definitely going to follow up on some of the issues you have from here, seeing as i'm using ComponentArt and Atlas together as well.